Skip to content
HomeVideosBooks
AllTopicsTrends
BlogsPodcasts
HistoryListsWatch laterLiked videosFollowing

The videos, books, blogs and podcasts Hacker News keeps recommending, all in one place.

VideosBooksBlogsPodcastsAboutPrivacySettings

Data from Hacker News, HackerTube, HackerBooks, HackerBlogs and Open Library. Credits · Not affiliated with Y Combinator.

HomeVideosBooksBlogsPodcasts
Ctrl K
    Cover of The foundations of mathematics

    The foundations of mathematics

    Ian Stewart, David Orme Tall · 1977

    The transition from school mathematics to university mathematics is seldom straightforward. Students are faced with a disconnect between the algorithmic and informal attitude to mathematics at school, versus a new emphasis on proof, based on logic, and a more abstract development of general concepts, based on set theory. The authors have many years' experience of the potential difficulties involved, through teaching first-year undergraduates and researching the ways in which students and mathematicians think. The book explains the motivation behind abstract foundational material based on students' experiences of school mathematics, and explicitly suggests ways students can make sense of formal ideas. This second edition takes a significant step forward by not only making the transition from intuitive to formal methods, but also by reversing the process- using structure theorems to prove that formal systems have visual and symbolic interpretations that enhance mathematical thinking. This is exemplified by a new chapter on the theory of groups. While the first edition extended counting to infinite cardinal numbers, the second also extends the real numbers rigorously to larger ordered fields. This links intuitive ideas in calculus to the formal epsilon-delta methods of analysis. The approach here is not the conventional one of 'nonstandard analysis', but a simpler, graphically based treatment which makes the notion of an infinitesimal natural and straightforward.

    Mathematics
    Open LibraryAmazon
    Stats for nerds
    6recommend
    6mentions
    6people
    2008–2022years
    100% recommend

    Mentions per year

    20082010201220142016201820202022

    What Hacker News says

    1. tanganianJun 2022
      The Foundations of Mathematics - Ian Stewart.

      I wouldn't say it taught me the most, but more like it opened the door so I could learn the most out of everything after it.

      thread
    2. newsoulMay 2022
      After reading all the comments I am sharing my choices

      1. The foundations of mathematics by Stewart and Tall

      2. Problem Solving Strategies by Arthur Engels

      3. Journey into Mathematics by Rotman

      4. Concrete Mathematics by Knuth et al.

      thread
    3. smarx007May 2022
      I would suggest to start with reading The Foundations of Mathematics by Stewart and Tall: https://global.oup.com/ukhe/product/the-foundations-of-mathe...

      This will give you an understanding of which topics make sense to you and which you can barely follow. From that, you will need to catch up but where from depends only on your level. I guess, you might have some Khan Academying to do to catch up with the school program.

      After you are done with The Foundations of Mathematics, I think you can take Andrew Ng's courses and go from there. I also use https://www.routledge.com/A-Concise-Handbook-of-Mathematics-... as a general reference when I need to look up a topic a have a rather vague recollection of.

      thread
    4. jonsenMar 2022
      > I've never understood the obsession with Spivak

      Maybe one can be so happy about having made it through such a tough subject that it has to be a good book? I mean, do people normaly study from more than one text?!

      > ...to give people a flavour of university style mathematics

      I've just started The Foundations of Mathematics by Ian Stewart & David Tall. So far it's really promising.

      thread
    5. haZard_OSMar 2018
      Others here have offered some great suggestions already, so I will offer one a little off the beaten path:

      Foundations of Mathematics https://www.amazon.com/Foundations-Mathematics-Ian-Stewart/d...

      This book is meant to help one transition from performing math in an algorithmic manner to generating proofs based on logic and also set theory.

      thread
    6. jonpFeb 2008
      "1089 and all that" by David Acheson is charming and very readable. It covers a variety of different types of maths but more importantly get across what maths is really about. I've bought it for friends and family with a wide range of maths backgrounds (graduate mathematicians to not-since-school-forty-years-ago).

      Also "Alice and Numberland", Baylis and Haggarty; and "The Foundations of Mathematics", Stewart and Tall. These are both pitched somewhere between high school and university level and bridge the gap well.

      thread

    Related

    Cover of 1089 and All That - A Journey into Mathematics
    2008–2015

    1089 and All That - A Journey into Mathematics

    David Acheson
    2 recommend · 4
    Cover of Journey into Mathematics
    2022

    Journey into Mathematics

    Joseph J. Rotman
    3 recommend · 3
    Cover of Concrete mathematics
    2007–2026

    Concrete mathematics

    Ronald L. Graham
    140 recommend · 312
    Cover of Concepts of modern mathematics
    2009–2026

    Concepts of modern mathematics

    Ian Stewart
    12 recommend · 19
    Cover of The Great Mathematical Problems
    2025

    The Great Mathematical Problems

    Ian Stewart
    2 recommend · 2
    Cover of Complex analysis
    2020

    Complex analysis

    Ian Stewart
    2 recommend · 2
    Cover of The Princeton Companion to Mathematics
    2009–2025

    The Princeton Companion to Mathematics

    Timothy Gowers
    62 recommend · 101
    Cover of Practical foundations of mathematics
    2009–2016

    Practical foundations of mathematics

    Taylor, Paul
    4 recommend · 5