Skip to content
HomeVideosBooks
AllTopicsTrends
BlogsPodcasts
HistoryListsWatch laterLiked videosFollowing

The videos, books, blogs and podcasts Hacker News keeps recommending, all in one place.

VideosBooksBlogsPodcastsAboutPrivacySettings

Data from Hacker News, HackerTube, HackerBooks, HackerBlogs and Open Library. Credits · Not affiliated with Y Combinator.

HomeVideosBooksBlogsPodcasts
Ctrl K
    Cover of Architecture as metaphor

    Architecture as metaphor

    Karatani, Kōjin · 1995

    "In Architecture as Metaphor, Karatani detects a recurrent "will to architecture" that he argues is the foundation of all Western thinking, traversing architecture, philosophy, literature, linguistics, city planning, anthropology, political economics, psychoanalysis, and mathematics. In the three parts of the book, he analyzes the complex bonds between construction and deconstruction, thereby pointing to an alternative model of "secular criticism," but in the domain of philosophy rather than literary or cultural criticism." "As Karatani claims in his introduction, because the will to architecture is practically nonexistent in Japan, he must first assume a dual role: one that affirms the architectonic (by scrutinizing the suppressed function of form) and one that pushes formalism to its collapse (by invoking Kurt Godel's incompleteness theorem). His subsequent discussions trace a path through the work of Christopher Alexander, Jane Jacobs, Gilles Deleuze, and others. Finally, amidst the drive that motivates all formalization, he confronts an unbridgeable gap, an uncontrollable event encountered in the exchange with the other; thus his speculation turns toward global capital movement. While in the present volume he mainly analyzes familiar Western texts, it is precisely for this reason that his voice discloses a distance that will add a new dimension to our English-language discourse."--Jacket.

    PhilosophyDesign & UX
    Open LibraryAmazon
    Stats for nerds
    1recommend
    3mentions
    2people
    2018–2022years
    67% recommend33% neutral

    Mentions per year

    20182019202020212022

    What Hacker News says

    1. closetkantianNov 2022
      Architecture as Metaphor by Kojin Karatani.
      thread
    2. closetkantianNov 2022
      Architecture as Metaphor: Language, Number, Money by Kojin Karatani. Awesome interdisciplinary work that let me understand some mathematics (coming from a background in Philosophy and Literature).
      thread
    3. sewercakeJul 2018
      It's interesting. Apparently, in mid-to-late 20th century, the discipline of architecture was bursting with self-described architects who rarely, if ever, had buildings created.

      They instead focused on architectural 'theory', which meant anything from phenomenological approaches to space (Gaston Bachelard), to 'Architecture as Metaphor' (see book with same title by Kojin_Karatani, a critical theorist), hell, even theory-fiction (Benjamin H. Bratton).

      A whole generation (or two, three?) of theorists have spent lots of time intellectualizing and philosophizing what, for a long time, seemed to be a design-oriented, practical discipline.

      I wish I had sources for this -- it's only through informal conversations with practicing architects and theorists that I learned these things.

      thread

    Related

    Cover of The Timeless Way of Building
    2008–2026

    The Timeless Way of Building

    Christopher Alexander
    67 recommend · 134
    Cover of Universal principles of design
    2007–2024

    Universal principles of design

    William Lidwell
    24 recommend · 42
    Cover of The Architecture of Happiness
    2010–2020

    The Architecture of Happiness

    Alain De Botton
    4 recommend · 4
    Cover of Notes on the synthesis of form
    2009–2026

    Notes on the synthesis of form

    Christopher Alexander
    34 recommend · 94
    Cover of Design paradigms
    2014–2018

    Design paradigms

    Henry Petroski
    4 recommend · 4
    Social ArchitecturePieter Hintjens
    2016–2021

    Social Architecture

    Pieter Hintjens
    8 recommend · 24
    Cover of Clean Architecture
    2012–2026

    Clean Architecture

    Robert C. Martin
    47 recommend · 142
    Cover of Metaphors We Live By
    2009–2026

    Metaphors We Live By

    George Lakoff
    56 recommend · 109