Skip to content
HomeVideosBooks
AllTopicsTrends
BlogsPodcasts
HistoryListsWatch laterLiked videosFollowing

The videos, books, blogs and podcasts Hacker News keeps recommending, all in one place.

VideosBooksBlogsPodcastsAboutPrivacySettings

Data from Hacker News, HackerTube, HackerBooks, HackerBlogs and Open Library. Credits · Not affiliated with Y Combinator.

HomeVideosBooksBlogsPodcasts
Ctrl K
    Cover of Seeing red

    Seeing red

    Nicholas Humphrey · 2006

    "Consciousness matters. Arguably it matters more than anything. The purpose of this book is to build toward an explanation of just what the matter is." "Nicholas Humphrey begins this exploration of the biggest of big questions with a challenge to the reader, and himself. What's involved in "seeing red"? What is it like for us to see someone else seeing something red?" "Seeing a red screen tells us a fact about something in the world. But it also creates a new fact - a sensation in each of our minds, the feeling of redness. And that's the mystery. Conventional science so far hasn't told us what conscious sensations are made of, or how we get access to them, or why we have them at all. From an evolutionary perspective, what's the point of consciousness?" "Humphrey offers a daring and novel solution, arguing that sensations are not things that happen to us, they are things we do - originating in our primordial ancestors' expressions of liking or disgust. Tracing the evolutionary trajectory through to human beings, he shows how this has led to sensations playing the key role in the human sense of Self. The Self, as we now know it from within, seems to have fascinating other worldly properties. It leads us to believe in mind body duality and the existence of a soul. And such beliefs, even if mistaken, can be highly adaptive, because they increase the value we place on our own and otherʼ lives.

    Psychology & BehaviorPhilosophy
    Open LibraryAmazon
    Stats for nerds
    3recommend
    3mentions
    3people
    2012–2024years
    100% recommend

    Mentions per year

    2012201420162018202020222024

    What Hacker News says

    1. lambdaoneMar 2024
      As a sidelight on this, I thought I'd also mention the book "Seeing Red: A Study in Consciousness" by Nicholas Humphrey, which advances a similar argument, but with brain output instead of body state as the driver of sensation.
      thread
    2. truculentNov 2023
      Humphrey also has a book called “Seeing Red” that covers similar ground that I found quite compelling, too
      thread
    3. jbrechtelMar 2012
      Are you saying you see no evolutionary purpose for consciousness? This is a (very short) interesting book on the topic: http://www.amazon.com/Seeing-Red-Consciousness-Behavior-Init...
      thread

    Related

    Cover of The Black Swan
    2007–2026

    The Black Swan

    Nassim Nicholas Taleb
    263 recommend · 862
    Cover of Blindsight
    2009–2026

    Blindsight

    Peter Watts
    214 recommend · 385
    Cover of The Blank Slate
    2007–2024

    The Blank Slate

    Steven Pinker
    42 recommend · 100
    Cover of The red book =
    2013–2026

    The red book =

    Carl Gustav Jung
    10 recommend · 20
    Cover of Outliers
    2008–2026

    Outliers

    Malcolm Gladwell
    99 recommend · 350
    Cover of Blink
    2007–2026

    Blink

    Malcolm Gladwell
    29 recommend · 152
    Cover of Shadows of the mind
    2008–2026

    Shadows of the mind

    Roger Penrose
    13 recommend · 43
    Cover of Red Plenty
    2010–2026

    Red Plenty

    Francis Spufford
    71 recommend · 113