Chris Pirillo
4 HN mentions · mentioned in 4 months, 2012–2014
4:21 · 1.9M views · Mar 8, 2012
Chris Pirillo has his father try Windows 8 for the first time to see how ordinary users cope with the new interface.
Cited critically, as evidence that Windows 8 would frustrate ordinary users, especially without a start button.
4 comments from Hacker News
Yeah, I was shocked by the "dad" test: this video And when Gabe talked about 8, I winced: [LINK] But watching a few "tips" / "best of new features" videos for 8.1... I start to feel a little left out. Just type to search. Re-engineered file copying. Hot corners make it seem like someone at least skimmed an article on Fitt's Law. And, ooh, Win + Print Screen? Just make the screenshot a file. Yeah, should have been fixed back in 95. So, er, maybe they got a few things right? I haven't upgraded yet, but... the dissonance is mounting.
They didn't need to take away the start button, and it's going frustrate a lot of users. See: this video I've been running the preview in a VM, and getting back to the launcher frustrated me so much I had to install a small utility made by Stardock that makes a fake start button that takes you to the launcher: [LINK] . I'm a Mac guy, but my job requires me to be in Windows half the time. I hope they take a hint from Stardock and that video and put the start button back in.
This WAS predicted by many users and blogs prior to the release of Windows 8. Criticisms started a year prior to the official release of Windows 8, with the consumer preview version. Here's one of the videos. this video This article was written shortly after the release but it does one of the best jobs of explaining how poor the usability of the OS is. [LINK]
Tried using it in a virtual machine, but was an endlessly frustrating experience in Windows 8 (Metro) UI. It's like going from an iPhone to a Blackberry -- you want to touch the screen, but can't. Be prepared to be your family's help desk if they're buying a new machine: this video