George Collier
2 HN recommenders · recommended in 3 months, 2021–2026
0:52 · 3.3M views · Jul 15, 2021
A one-minute clip of Jacob Collier tuning a piano, remarking that it is not in tune at all. It touches on his views on equal temperament and tuning.
Used as an example in music theory and tuning discussions of continuous-pitch thinking beyond equal temperament.
3 comments from Hacker News
> On continuous pitch instruments (e.g. violin, voice), this is entirely possible to do Jacob Collier has a good example of this[1] (I'm a huge fan). Separately, I've previously heard this referred to as "equal temperament" tuning which makes me wonder what led to this difference in wording. [1]: this video
> adjust between A440 and A400 Someone shared this recently: this video I struggle to conceive being able to hear the difference, but _singing_ it entirely blows my mind
Ever really loved a classical piano song? No? Maybe you just don't like the controversial new way we've been tuning pianos for the last ~200 years. Check out the 1/4 comma meantone version of Mozart Fantasie KV397 [1] which you can compare to equal temperament. (Please note this piece was unfinished, and the final section is believed to have been written by someone else.) My secret love is Chopin Ballade No. 4 Op. 52 in unequal temperament [2]. Last year this video had ~4k views. I may be responsible for 1k and it's now ~8k views. You can compare a good ET version Krystian Zimmerman [3]. Jacob Collier has referred to Equal Temperament as a "hoax" [4] [1]: [LINK] [2]: [LINK] [3]: [LINK] [4]: this video