
Patrick Boyle
2 HN recommenders · recommended in 6 months, 2024–2025
32:55 · 3.2M views · Apr 16, 2024
Patrick Boyle's deadpan account of Saudi Arabia's Neom and The Line megaproject, a planned 170 km linear city that has been scaled back to a fraction of its size. He covers the feasibility problems and the financing.
Recommended as the entertaining, skeptical overview of Neom whenever its progress comes up.
7 comments from Hacker News
It was kind of a duff idea from the start. Patrick Boyles youtube Neom - The Line - The Rise and Fall of Saudi Arabia's Linear City this video is rather epic if you haven't seen it.
I think not. They probably mean the planned project would use one fifth of the world's steel but it is currently just a hole in the ground and the project is kind of ridiculous and won't get built as planned - even the Saudis don't have enough money. Patrick Boyle had an entertaining youtube on it this video
Patrick Boyle's channel on Youtube did a great video on this. this video It seems unfeasible, bordering on impossible, and also a terrible idea even if aliens came down and built it for us tomorrow.
It's been rather extraordinary. The Patrick Boyle vid on Neom done about a year ago was entertaining ( this video ). As might be expected that's all ground to a halt now.
Doesn't count. Egypt's New Administrative Capital is located only 45km east of Cairo. Whereas previous epic fails on relocating capitals (/planned cities): - Nigeria's Abuja (1991) [0] is 330 mi/530 km northeast of Lagos, 1h20 by plane or 12hr by car. Fairly successful relocation. - Myanmar's Naypyidaw (2008) is 320 km/200 mi north of Yangon [1] Claimed 2025 population 930K, actual 780-900K. - Indonesia's Nusantara ("will be fully finished in five phases by 2045, coinciding with the 100th anniversary of Indonesia") is on Borneo, 870 mi/11400 km and one island northeast of Jakarta [2] - also Saudi Arabia previously had King Abdullah Economic City (KAEC, planned since 2005), not a capital replacement: a planned city, intended as a logistics and manufacturing hub. Planned population: 2 million; actual 2002 population: only 7,000. [3] KAEC is referenced in the epic totally-not-sarcastic video Patrick Boyle on "Neom - The Line - The Rise and Fall of Saudi Arabia's Linear City" [4]. [0]: [LINK] [1]: [LINK] [2]: [LINK] [3]: [LINK] [4]: this video