The autobiography of an unknown Indian

What Hacker News says

1. sashank_1509Sep 2024
   Have you read any books at all by Indians who lived through the British empire. Maybe start with “My Experiments with Truth” by Gandhi. The caricature that some modern Indians have made of the British empire would make even Gandhi turn in his grave.

   But if you want to read something really heretic, maybe try reading An autobiography of an unknown Indian by Niraj Choudhary. Choudhary was a British raj supporter, as in an Indian who opposed Indian independence. Does that shock you? There were actually quite a lot of them, more than you’d expect.

   Then if you want to get really metal, read in his own words, by Subedar Sitaram Pande. Sitaram Pande, was a soldier for the bengal army, for the British empire from 1812 to 1860, it’s one of the rare first author accounts we get of an Indian in that era. It will give you a glimpse of how an Indian at that time thought generally (hint: it was far more dominated by caste than you’d expect), how he viewed the empire and his relation to it. At that point I would say you are ready to try to understand Indian history that is not an avengers movie plot.

   I would follow it with CK Majumdars history of modern India, one of the best historians so committed to the truth that Nehru had to throw him out of the government and try to prevent him from writing his book. Don’t worry, he’s not an heretic, he was an Indian freedom fighter, but you will find that he was far more honest about his life under Britain, under Indian national Congress and the state of the country in different periods of time (he also has a 12 volume set covering India for over 2000 years that I never had a chance to complete).

   Show morethread
2. dmanAug 2010
   Non technical - Autobiography of an unknown Indian. Technical - Little Schemer.
   thread
3. dwwoelfelAug 2010
   Autobiography of an unknown Indian: http://www.amazon.com/o/ASIN/094032282X/

   Little Schemer: http://www.amazon.com/o/ASIN/0262560992/

   thread
4. ahazred8taSep 2024
   Choudhary's Autobiography of an unknown Indian

   https://archive.org/details/autobiographyofu0000nira

   thread