When God talks back

Name: When God talks back
ISBN: 9780307957504

T. M. Luhrmann · 2012

Psychological anthropologist Luhrmann offers an extended case study examining how believers come to have faith in an active, present God despite secular pressures in contemporary America. Drawing on extensive interviews and personal experience among Vineyard Movement members, Luhrmann focuses on the use of prayer among charismatic evangelical Christians. Her work combines personal narratives and excerpts from bestselling evangelical how-to guides with theories and data from psychology.

Religion & Spirituality Psychology & Behavior

Open Library Amazon

Stats for nerds

1recommend

2mentions

2people

2017–2019years

50% recommend50% neutral

Mentions per year

What Hacker News says

photojoshApr 2019
> no way that bicameralism would be the dominant phenotype only a few thousand years ago
It would be cultural and taught, not genetic.
There are non-isolated populations: I come from a religious background where the idea that God "talks" to you is quite prevalent. If you want an analysis of how could possibly be the case in our modern society, I recommend Tanya Luhrmann's "When God Talks Back".
I say Jaynes puts the transition as far too sudden compared to what it actually could have been. Individuals could have had developed his version of "consciousness" often and repeatedly, but failed to pass it on into greater culture. I think of literacy as an analogous transition; until it's actually of benefit for the average person to read+write (ie society has moved beyond majority subsistence), it's not going to happen.
[0] https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/12958803-when-god-talks-...
thread
ApocryphonMay 2017
I wouldn't be too certain about that. There are Christian- specifically American Evangelical Christian- approaches to responding to such voices in a positive way:
http://www.npr.org/2012/03/26/149394987/when-god-talks-back-... http://www.nytimes.com/2012/04/29/books/review/when-god-talk...
These Evangelicals seem to be the American equivalent to the Masai who speak to the dead.
thread