
[Phone rings]
Employee thinks: “Oh-oh… What should I do?”
Company with a strategy:
Employee says on the phone: “We don’t do that”
— Build a Better Life by Stealing Office Supplies: Dogbert's Big Book of Business, Scott Adams, 1991
— Dogbert, Build a Better Life by Stealing Office Supplies (Dogbert’s Big Book of Business), Scott Adams, 1991
Note the word “peer,” though.
I would not peer review papers on robotics or AI, as those are not my forté. I could review papers on some generalizations of software engineering or the Swift programming language.
Editing is a different matter. My mother was a scientific editor, and absolutely brutal. She edited a book I wrote on writing software for a certain specialty of Web site, and it was quite humbling. She knew nothing at all about the technology, yet provided an immensely valuable service.
The book is long past it’s “sell-by” date, yet stands as maybe the only “perfect” artifact of my life, thanks to her.
Then there’s comment threads in venues like this one, which some might equate to “peer review.”
There was an old Dilbert comic on Peer review. I don’t think it can be found online, but was in “Build a Better Life by Stealing Office Supplies.”
It was entitled “The Joy of Feedback,” and probably applies to comment threads.